Italian Thanksgiving Menu—American Meets Italy
Introduction
An Italian Thanksgiving menu fuses the heartwarming comfort of classic American festivities with the vibrant, authentic flavors of Italy. This cross-cultural feast brings a delightful twist to your holiday table—think roasted turkey with herby Italian seasonings, velvety parmesan mashed potatoes, and luscious tiramisu for dessert. It’s a celebration that brings everyone together for a meal that’s both familiar and fresh, perfect for impressing guests or elevating your family feast.
Why You’ll Love This Italian Thanksgiving Menu
This menu stands out by blending beloved American Thanksgiving staples with Italian ingredients and flair. Imagine rich flavors like garlic, rosemary, extra virgin olive oil, and plenty of cheese alongside your traditional favorites. The result? Each bite delivers both classic comfort and a Mediterranean spark, making it a crowd-pleaser for guests of all ages and tastes.
Italian-American Thanksgiving Menu Overview
Here’s how you can bring Italy to your Thanksgiving table with ease—no culinary degree required! This menu includes four show-stopping courses:
- Italian Herb Roasted Turkey: Infused with rosemary, garlic, and lemon.
- Parmesan Mashed Potatoes: Creamy, cheesy potatoes with a luxurious Italian finish.
- Sage and Pancetta Stuffing: Rustic bread, crispy pancetta, and plenty of fresh sage.
- Tiramisu: An elegant, coffee-laced Italian dessert to end the meal on a high note.
Key Ingredients for an Italian-American Feast
Give your Thanksgiving that delicious Italian twist with a few essential ingredients:
Ingredients
💡Meal Planning Tip: Save this menu to automatically generate a shopping list sorted by grocery store section—the perfect way to streamline your shopping and meal prep for a stress-free holiday.

Instructions
- Italian Herb Roasted Turkey: Preheat oven to 325°F. In a bowl, combine olive oil, minced garlic, rosemary, thyme, lemon zest, and juice. Rub the mixture all over and under the turkey skin. Season generously with salt and pepper. Roast according to turkey weight (about 13–15 minutes per pound), basting occasionally. Let rest before carving.
- Parmesan Mashed Potatoes: Boil potatoes until fork-tender. Drain and mash with warm milk, butter, and grated parmesan. Season to taste and whip until silky.
- Sage and Pancetta Stuffing: In a skillet, cook pancetta until crispy, add onion and celery to soften, then stir in sage and nutmeg. Toss with bread cubes and broth until evenly moistened. Transfer to a baking dish and bake at 350°F for 35 minutes.
- Tiramisu: Beat egg yolks with sugar. Fold in mascarpone, then gently fold in whipped cream. Mix espresso and liqueur. Dip ladyfingers briefly and layer with mascarpone cream in a dish. Repeat layers, ending with cream. Dust with cocoa and chill for 4 hours.
Serving Suggestions for Your Italian Thanksgiving Table
Set your table with vibrant antipasti, like marinated olives, roasted peppers, or a simple Caprese salad. Serve the turkey on a platter surrounded by fresh herbs and citrus slices for an aromatic presentation. Garnish mashed potatoes and stuffing with more fresh herbs. Dish up tiramisu in individual cups for a refined finish to your fusion feast.
Nutritional Information and Serving Size
This menu generously serves 8–10 people. A typical serving (including all four courses) averages around 800–1000 calories, depending on portion size and any optional additions.
Italian Thanksgiving Menu—Recap
Bringing together the best of both culinary worlds, this Italian Thanksgiving menu infuses classic holiday fare with the richness and warmth of Italian cooking—making your holiday meal uniquely memorable.
Weekly Meal Planning
This Italian-American Thanksgiving menu fits perfectly into a weekly meal prep plan, letting you get a head start on holiday prep. Save and schedule this menu to coordinate prep times, batch similar ingredients for multiple recipes, and avoid last-minute shopping stress.
Planning Benefits:
- Automatically consolidates all menu ingredients, so you know exactly what (and how much) to buy
- Makes efficient shopping lists organized by store—deli, dairy, produce, etc.
- Eliminates ingredient shortage surprises during your big cook
- Keeps your entire holiday meal (and weeknight dinners) on track
Pro tip: When you plan multiple holiday and weeknight meals with CookifyAI, your shopping list will always be optimized for efficiency and reduced waste. Try scheduling your recipes in advance right here!
Cook and Prep Times
Prep Time: 1.5 hours
Cook Time: 3 hours (for turkey and sides)
Total Time: Approx. 4.5 hours (including tiramisu chilling)
Enjoy this Italian Thanksgiving feast—a gathering that feels like home, wherever you are!




































